skip to Main Content

Media post: Trade-in or Sell? Exploring your Options for a Financed Car

When it comes to parting ways with your financed car, the decision between trading it in or selling it privately can be a daunting one. Each option comes with its own set of pros and cons, and the choice you make can significantly impact your financial outcome. In this guide, we’ll explore the intricacies of both trade-ins and private sales to help you make an informed decision.

Trade-In Pros and Cons

  1. Convenience

Pros: Trade-ins are convenient. You can simply visit a dealership, get your car evaluated, and potentially drive away with a new one.

Cons: Convenience often comes at a cost. Dealerships are in the business of making a profit, and the offer you receive may be lower than what you could get through a private sale.

  1. Speed of Transaction

Pros: Trade-ins are usually quicker than private sales. The dealership takes care of the paperwork, and you can be done in a matter of hours.

Cons: The speed comes at a price. Dealerships might rush the appraisal process, leading to a lower offer for your vehicle.

  1. Outstanding Loan Handling

Pros: Dealerships can handle paying off your existing loan, simplifying the process for you.

Cons: If you owe more on the car than it’s worth, the remaining balance may be rolled into your new loan, putting you in a negative equity situation.

Private Sale Pros and Cons

Maximizing Value

Pros: Selling privately often yields a higher return on your investment. You have more control over the pricing, negotiations, and final sale amount.

Cons: It can take time and effort to find the right buyer willing to pay your asking price.

Flexibility in Pricing

Pros: Private sales allow you to set the price based on the market value of your car. You’re not restricted to the dealer’s offer.

Cons: Setting the right price requires research, and overpricing might discourage potential buyers.

Handling Outstanding Loan

Pros: You have more control over your outstanding loan. If the car’s value is higher than what you owe, you can use the surplus to pay down other debts.

Cons: You’re responsible for handling the loan payoff, which can be a complex process involving coordination between you, the buyer, and the lender.

Factors to Consider

  1. Market Conditions

Consider the demand for your specific make and model. In a seller’s market, a private sale might be more lucrative, while a trade-in might be preferable in a buyer’s market.

  1. Condition of the Car

The better the condition of your car, the more likely you are to get a good price in a private sale. If your vehicle has issues, a trade-in might be a more practical option.

  1. Time Constraints

If you need to sell your car quickly, a trade-in might be the better option. Private sales can take weeks or even months to finalize.

  1. Negotiation Skills

If you’re a savvy negotiator and comfortable with the selling process, a private sale can be financially rewarding. If negotiation isn’t your strong suit, a trade-in might be a more stress-free

What happens to a loan when you trade it in?

Trading in a car with a loan involves transferring both the car and the debt attached to it. Here’s how it usually goes:

  1. Dealer pays off your old loan: The dealer negotiates your car’s trade-in value, effectively buying it from you. They use this value to pay off your existing loan with your lender. If the trade-in covers the entire loan balance, you’re good to go!

  1. Rollover into new loan: If your remaining loan amount exceeds the trade-in value, you have “negative equity.” In this case, the dealer “rolls over” the remaining debt into your new car loan. This increases your new loan’s total balance and potentially its interest rate, affecting your future payments.

  1. Paperwork shuffle: The dealership acts as the middleman, handling all the paperwork with your old and new lender. They pay off your existing loan, receive the car title, and facilitate the title transfer for your new car.

Trading in a car with a loan can simplify the process but might come with increased costs due to potential negative equity. Weighing the trade-in value, loan balance, and new loan terms is crucial before making a decision.

How to trade in a financed car?

Trading in a financed car involves several steps to ensure a smooth and successful transaction.

First, assess the current market value of your vehicle to determine its worth. This can be done through online tools, dealership appraisals, or consulting automotive valuation guides.

Next, contact your lender to obtain the current payoff amount on your auto loan. This amount represents the total outstanding balance you need to settle to own the vehicle outright. If the market value of your car is higher than the loan payoff, you may have positive equity, providing an advantage in the trade-in process.

Conversely, if the loan payoff exceeds the car’s value, you’ll have negative equity. When visiting a dealership for a trade-in, be prepared to negotiate both the trade-in value and the terms of your new financing arrangement. Ensure that the dealer pays off the existing loan promptly and handles all necessary paperwork to transfer ownership. It’s crucial to carefully review the terms of the new loan to ensure they align with your financial goals.

Is it a good idea to trade in a financed car?

Can you trade in a financed car? Yes, but the feasibility depends on various factors, such as the loan amount, trade-in value, and terms of the new loan. If you have negative equity, where you owe more than the car’s value, trading in may result in additional costs over time.


The decision to trade in or sell your financed car privately depends on your priorities and circumstances. If you value convenience and a quick transaction, a trade-in may be the way to go. However, if maximizing the value of your car is your top priority and you’re willing to invest time and effort, a private sale could be more financially rewarding. Carefully consider the factors discussed, and weigh the pros and cons to determine the option that aligns best with your goals and preferences.

Leave a Reply

Back To Top